High Court rules PIP changes are 'discriminatory'

Today the High Court ruled that changes to Personal Independence Payment (PIP) regulations introduced in March 2017 were "blatantly discriminatory" against people with mental health conditions.

Mr Justice Mostyn issued a written ruling which said: "In my judgment, the 2017 regulations introduced criteria ... which were blatantly discriminatory against those with mental health impairments and which cannot be objectively justified."

Mark Atkinson, Chief Executive at disability charity Scope, said: 
 
“Today’s judgement is immensely significant for the thousands of disabled people affected by the misconceived changes to PIP earlier this year.
 
“The regulations introduced in March make crude and unfair distinctions between those with physical impairments and mental health conditions.
 
“Thousands of disabled people rely on PIP to live independently and help meet the often substantial extra costs they face related to their condition or impairment. 
 
“The Government must listen carefully to today’s ruling and act quickly to reverse these changes, rather than further dragging the issue through the courts.”

 

Notes to the editor:

For more information please contact the Press Office on 0207 619 7200 or email pressoffice@scope.org.uk.

Type:

south 1 west 2 Attitudes 23 Media 5 Politics 20 Welfare 28 Children and families 5 Social care 15 Living 7 Standards 1 awkward 5 awkwardness 1 disability 82 disabled 76 Allowance 2 DLA 7 Independence 14 Payment; 1 Personal 14 PIP; 2 donate 1 fundraising 5 Retail 1 shops 2 StripForScope 1 assisted 3 die 1 dying 2 Scope 37 suicide 4 commission 6 costs 18 equipment 1 extra 18 wheelchair 3 extra costs 14 disabled children 3 exhausted 1 frustrated 1 parents 1 stressed 1 support 6 benefits 19 Chancellor 4 payments 1 PIP 24 Freud's statement 1 Minimum wage 1 Work 20 assisted dying 4 assisted suicide 3 board 1 chair 3 employment 45 employment and support allowance 2 House of Lords 2 children 3 children's 1 commissioner 1 listen 1 Disabled; 1 expensive 1 Life 2 more; 1 People; 2 Powered 1 Wheelchairs 1 Energy 7 families 2 fuel 1 poverty 2 Care 14 Learning 3 People 28 Residential 1 Social 13 View 2 Winterbourne 2 WCA 3 work capability assessment 3 and 3 Autumn 4 Carers 1 CSA 1 Health 5 Investment 1 Older 1 Statement; 2 Jobs 3 Payment 13 Independent living fund 1 accessibility 4 transport 5 charity 18 Gray 1 review 3 work programme 2 Access 2 Reasonable 1 discrimination 3 MS 1 multiple sclerosis 1 right-to-die 1 honours 2 new year honours 2 CBE 1 Adjustment 1 integration 1 NHS 2 £1bn 1 fund 3 growth 2 labour 1 Local 2 market 1 community care 1 independent living 2 learning disability 2 Winterbourne View 1 end the awkward 5 employers 1 gap 11 actors 1 Cameron 1 Downing 1 End 3 Face2Face 1 Samantha 1 Street 1 the 3 Fisher 1 Hindle 1 Robin 1 campaigns 1 green 3 paper 3 parliament 2 Access-to-Work 1 benefit sanctions 2 Department of Work and Pensions 3 Accounts 1 Committee 3 Institution 1 Public 1 (PAC) 1 Election 2 Morgan 1 Patron 1 Sophie 1 Access to Work 2 economic growth 1 employment gap 8 disabled people 17 ONS 4 Queen speech 2 Alex 1 ambassador 1 Brooker 1 Experiences 1 First 1 Impressions 1 Court 2 delays 1 High 1 unlawful 1 appointment 1 Chief 2 Executive 2 interim 1 £550 1 Cost 1 more 1 ILF 1 Independent 3 dating 1 Day 1 International 1 Kiss 1 Kissing 1 relationships 1 disability living allowance 1 employment support allowance 6 ESA 9 Alex Brooker 1 Channel 4 1 faux 1 gaffes 1 Last Leg 1 pas 1 Shorts 1 Dignitas; 1 Dying; 1 Scope; 3 Duncan 1 Iain 1 Reform 1 Smith 1 homes 1 regulator 1 self-regulation 1 devolution 1 northern 1 powerhouse 1 Sheffield 1 A to Z 1 sex 1 Conference 2 IDS 1 Party 1 Tory 1 derby 1 fan 1 Football 1 Merseyside 1 pretending 1 Appointments 1 Atkinson 1 Mark 1 New 1 autism 1 Connor 1 difficulties 1 epilepsy 1 Sparrowhawk 1 welfare to work 1 work and pensions 1 Comprehensive 2 Spending 2 DDA 1 Disability Discrimination Act 1 living standards 1 Experiences of social care 1 funding 1 2- 1 CSR 1 Statement 2 Donald 2 Kovaleski 2 Serge 2 Trump 2 gold-plated 1 Jenner 1 Kylie 1 J 1 reporter 1 Lego 1 toylikeme 1 toys 1 full 1 cuts 1 disability employment gap 5 Welfare Reform and Work Bill 1 profitability 1 profits 1 peers 1 consultation 2 2016 2 Budget 5 George Osborne 1 Personal Independence Payment 7 Stephen Crabb 1 Crabb 1 Pensions 1 Secretary 1 Stephen 1 Appeals 2 Daily 1 DWP 3 Mandatory 1 Mirror 1 Reconsideration 1 Barclays 1 BBC 1 diversity 2 Alliance 1 Consumers 2 London 1 Uber 1 Bill 1 Digital 3 Divide 1 Economy 2 Queen's 2 Speech 2 Internet 2 dog 1 guide 1 pound 1 purple 1 accessible 1 buses 2 users 1 EU 1 Europe 1 Referendum 1 May 1 Minister 2 Prime 1 Theresa 1 rio 1 RJ Mitte 2 Sophie Morgan 2 sport 2 Select Committee 1 Minister of State for Disabled People 1 Duke of Westminster 1 President 1 stories 1 HMRC 1 National Minimum Wage 1 paralympics 4 media representation 1 TV 1 TV representation 1 assessment 1 capability 1 Businessess 1 Conservative 1 CQC 1 adults 1 young 1 communications 1 Fundraising, Communications and Marketing 1 marketing 1 PR 1 press office 1 Tracy Griffin 1 A&E 1 Select 1 ACEVO 1 southern co-operative 1 Credit 1 Universal 1 council 1 tax 1 Mental Health 1 Prime Minister 1 Supreme 1 verdict 1 Wheelchair users 1 advertising 1 maltesers 1 media respresentation 1 government 5 industrial strategy 1 insurance 2 disabled customers 2 ofgem 1 fines 1 Legal change 1 Taxis 2 Books on the underground 1 literature 1 Improving 1 Lives 1 ; 1 apple 1 pay; 1 PIP assessment 5 online 1 GSK 1 disabled consumer 1 disabled consumers 1 CLG committee 1 Green paper 3 inequality 1 Equality and Human Rights Commission 1 equality act 1 PHVs 1 Private Hire Vehicle 1 taxi 1 taxi driver 1 wheelchair user 1 General 1 Everyday Equality 1 General Election 2017 1 airports 1 CAA 1 2012 1 Work With Me 2 Universal Credit 2 isolation 1 loneliness 1 Credit Universal 1 Work; 1 job 1 virgin media 1 festive activities 1 tribunals 1 high court 1 charges 1 hospital 1 parking 2 Esther McVey 2 Badges; 1 Blue 1 Club; 1 dinner; 1 Presidents 1 finance 1 Local Government 1 atos 1 capita 1 blue badges 1